“If my life could be contained in a word,” Edgar tells us, “it would be this one: accidents.” The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint, Brady Udall’s first novel, is filled with moments taken as either cruel jokes or benevolent miracles. From age seven, when he survives getting run over by a mail truck and is promptly abandoned by his mother, Edgar is shipped from Arizona to Pennsylvania and several states in between, shuttled from distant relatives to foster programs to reservation schools. His more permanent stay occurs when he is put into placement care in Richland, Utah with a Mormon family, and it is soon easy to see that, despite their vast differences, the family seems made for him. Half-Indian and half-white, unable to write since his accident and the constant victim of harassment and assault, it is not difficult ot distinguish a connection between Edgar and a family jeered at for being “inbred piece[s] of dirt.” Utah has long been typecast as a haven for fanatics and their multiple wives, but Udall bypasses these stereotypes for a tender portrait that avoids both simplifying and sugarcoating. Not one for overwrought descriptions, encompassing Richland winter as “gray and flat” with snow of “deliberate slowness,” Udall approaches family and faith through Edgar’s eyes, and gives a narrative that is plain spoken and poignant. Initially embracing conversion, he sees his baptism as “a huge choice in a world that, for me, had no real choices at all.” And while Mint takes some cues from Dickens’ Great Expectations, there are no characters over-styled for literary purposes, no Havishams or Magwitches. The Madsen family who accepts Edgar is dysfunctional in the tenderest of ways, that wrought by early tragedy, and the traditions of their prim, sepia-cast ancestors and increasingly rebellious, secularized children is a multi-layered conflict as absorbing as Udall’s earlier short stories. When Edgar goes on the final stage of his journey, it is a comparatively rushed affair. His time in Richland however, is like the crib foster father Clay once made of “the oak planks of the same covered wagon that brought the family so far,” beautifully crafted and the result of much patience.
- Melanie Jones